The Girl on the Milk Carton

Marcus Plowright

Director

Jonelle Matthews

Self - Murder Victim

Jonelle Matthews

Self - Story Subject

Christian Dalton

Self - Patrol Officer Mark Blaszkiewicz

Mike Prill

Self - Detective at Greeley Colorado Police Dept.

Steve Pankey

Self - Convicted of the 1984 Murder of Jonelle Matthews

Jennifer Mogensen

Self - Sister of Jonelle Matthews

Eileen Huff

Self - Matthews Family Friend

Eileen Huff

Self - Spearheaded the 'Rescue Jonelle' Search & Charity Efforts

Angela Hicks

Self - Former wife of Steve Pankey

Gloria Matthews

Self - Mother of Jonelle Matthews

Deanna Ross

Self - Best Friend of Jonelle Matthews

Russell Ross

Self - Father of Deanna Ross

Russell Ross

Self - Matthews' Family Friend

Mark Blasziewicz

Self - Patrol Officer at Greeley Colorado Police Dept.

Jim Matthews

Self - Father of Jonelle Matthews

Ronald Reagan

Self - Former U.S. President

Edward Dentzel

Self - True Crime and Missing Persons Podcaster

Jim Christy

Self - Former Matthews Family Pastor in Greeley Colorado

Michael Rourke

Self - Weld County District Attorney

Lacy Wells

Self - Weld County Deputy District Attorney

Robert Cash

Self - Detective at Greeley Colorado Police Dept.