Down the Hill: The Delphi Murders

Drew Iden

Self - Host, HLN's Down The Hill Podcast

Barbara MacDonald

Self - Host, HLN's Down The Hill Podcast

Doug Carter

Self - Indiana State Police

Kelsi German

Self - Libby's Sister

Becky Patty

Self - Libby's Grandmother

Arika Gibson

Self - Friend of Abby & Libby

Anna Williams

Self - Abby's Mother

Carrie Timmons

Self - Libby's Mother

Darrell Sterrett

Self - Former Delphi Fire Chief

Lindsey Eaton

Self - Reporter, Fox 59

Tobe Leazenby

Self - Sheriff, Carroll County, IN

Mike Patty

Self - Libby's Grandfather

Eric Erskin

Self - Abby's Grandfather

Kim Riley

Self - Retired Indiana State Police Spokesman

Kristine Lang

Self - Abby & Libby's Math Teacher

Julia Leahy

Self - Executive Director, Carroll County Chamber of Commerce

Jennaca Combs

Self - Area Resident

Jeff Rinek

Self - Former FBI Special Agent